• 1 Post
  • 32 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 27th, 2023

help-circle


  • We don’t have one right now and are enough people currently getting helped in those ways?

    Definitely not. Which I keep seeing as scarcity, whereas it’s actually a result of priorities.

    Having this conversation makes me feel a bit ashamed as I’m realising I’ve been brainwashed over the years by internalising what Work and Income and Ministry of Health keep telling me.

    Thanks for being patient in your explanation!


  • I think you are right. It’s bizarre the number of US “culture war” talking points and polarizations seem to be creeping in. I think the other thing is probably a huge number of New Zealanders now have spent their entire lives in the neoliberal economic paradigm and it’s hard for them to imagine alternatives to things like SOEs and revenue-driven media.

    but we don’t have one now and is the Govt helping you right now?

    I’m not sure I understand what you mean by this question. It feels rhetorical but I’m not sure what conclusion I’m intended to come to? The answer is in some ways and not in others.


  • One of my parents was very fond of that proverb. <3 Literally as well as metaphorically.

    I meant more I have a mindset in terms of society’s scarcity.

    The messaging drilled into me is always that the government can’t afford to give us all the things we need. So when people say the government should give everyone, say, a UBI, part of me panics thinking at that rate the day when the government decides it can, say, finally afford to help people like me to get a wheelchair, or help the homeless people up the road get shelter, or cut hospital wait times to under 12 months, will never come because all the money will go to UBIs.

    But that’s a false dichotomy.

    They’ve spent more money administering it than actually providing

    I get the impression this happens a fair bit with change to social programmes that is designed to send project an ideology. Sometimes it almost feels like there are two NZs, one that wants to help everyone become a prosperous society and one that wants to not have social support at all.


  • Oh, yeah I agree with the gist of this. I think you are right. In our legal system we have the principle that jailing innocent people is worse than accidentally letting a guilty one go unpunished, and I really wish we could apply that same logic to social programmes.

    The kind of witch hunting that goes on mostly affects and hurts those in need.

    I think my problem is I have a mindset of scarcity and should probably study macroeconomics or something.


  • Idk I’m in two minds about that. When I was at university I knew plenty of people who were living rent-free in their parents’ houses. One guy was even having his mum cook meals and do laundry.

    Whereas I was just out there by myself, so without an allowance my loans would have had even more of a chilling effect. In practice most suggestions for a UBI seem to involve lowering the amount poor people get. I guess the devil’s in the details.

    If I were in charge I’d make tertiary free instead.