Alphabet owns YouTube they set the rules, they host videos for free, sometimes they even pay users a portion of the ad revenue. YouTube is not a free (as in freedom) platform, it is a business. Choosing to base your income on that kind of platform is a risk, and users who do so should be extremely cautious about breaking rules on that platform.
Anyone is free to rent a VPS, install video hosting software, a message board, a blog, get advertisers who want to run ads on your site, and then you can do and say anything you want. Then YOU own the platform, you get to set the rules. But that takes a level of technical knowledge and personal responsibility that most ‘Career YouTubers’ are unwilling to take on.
Hear me out…maybe these services have grown so much they should be regulated as a utility just like the airwaves used to be. Not saying that will fix the problem, but will at least make them accountable beyond their opaque corporate structures and whims.
Maybe? The problem I have with that is they are not a radio station or TV station. or even an analog to one like a streaming service that provides access to local news/weather. They do not chose a bunch of programs to host and they generate a VERY small amount number of their own videos, they are a user generated content hosting site.
A comprehensive regulation of the conduct of a user generated content hosting services would have to be written by competent, intelligent, and technologically knowledgeable lawmakers. Otherwise it is guaranteed to make things worse for the end user (see age verification laws).
I don’t disagree with anything you’re saying. I’m certainly not competent enough to speak on anything close to the technical nuances. But something like radio stations, water and gas utitilites, or public transportation systems - while many in the us are for profit, once they get too large, they should be managed as a utility.
Like, “congrats. You’re idea was super great, you won capitalism” now as a community we have to regulate it because it has become so intertwined in the fabric of our lives.
Regulation is important. Good Regulation is essential to a functioning society…otherwise, people start talking about guillotines or Tea Parties.
Alphabet owns YouTube they set the rules, they host videos for free, sometimes they even pay users a portion of the ad revenue. YouTube is not a free (as in freedom) platform, it is a business. Choosing to base your income on that kind of platform is a risk, and users who do so should be extremely cautious about breaking rules on that platform.
Anyone is free to rent a VPS, install video hosting software, a message board, a blog, get advertisers who want to run ads on your site, and then you can do and say anything you want. Then YOU own the platform, you get to set the rules. But that takes a level of technical knowledge and personal responsibility that most ‘Career YouTubers’ are unwilling to take on.
Hear me out…maybe these services have grown so much they should be regulated as a utility just like the airwaves used to be. Not saying that will fix the problem, but will at least make them accountable beyond their opaque corporate structures and whims.
Maybe? The problem I have with that is they are not a radio station or TV station. or even an analog to one like a streaming service that provides access to local news/weather. They do not chose a bunch of programs to host and they generate a VERY small amount number of their own videos, they are a user generated content hosting site.
A comprehensive regulation of the conduct of a user generated content hosting services would have to be written by competent, intelligent, and technologically knowledgeable lawmakers. Otherwise it is guaranteed to make things worse for the end user (see age verification laws).
I don’t disagree with anything you’re saying. I’m certainly not competent enough to speak on anything close to the technical nuances. But something like radio stations, water and gas utitilites, or public transportation systems - while many in the us are for profit, once they get too large, they should be managed as a utility.
Like, “congrats. You’re idea was super great, you won capitalism” now as a community we have to regulate it because it has become so intertwined in the fabric of our lives.
Regulation is important. Good Regulation is essential to a functioning society…otherwise, people start talking about guillotines or Tea Parties.